Tendi is doing a surprising amount of work in the Star Trek Secret Lair value calculation. Her card is Thrasios, Triton Hero wearing a different name, which means the cheerful science officer arrives carrying most of her drop’s existing singles value. I like Lower Decks already. This feels like an unnecessarily effective way to get my attention.

Wizards revealed five drops yesterday, with a sixth still to come. Set Phasers to Superdrop launches November 9, 2026, at 9 a.m. Pacific. Each revealed drop costs $29.99 nonfoil or $39.99 foil. There’s also a spending-threshold promo, and the arithmetic on that deserves a minute before anybody starts building a cart.

I’d put Lower Decks first for someone who wants its actual cards. The other drops need a bigger allowance for loving Star Trek, and that allowance shrinks again when you cross off cards you already own.

Tendi, Exploring the Future, the Star Trek Secret Lair version of Thrasios, Triton Hero; its resale price is not yet established

Star Trek Secret Lair value, using existing copies

I checked Scryfall’s USD prices on October 28 and picked inexpensive, already released paper printings with a reported nonfoil price. That includes promo copies and an earlier crossover version. These are replacement-cost estimates before shipping and tax. They’re also retail reference numbers; selling the cards would leave you with less after fees and postage.

The new Star Trek treatments don’t have established prices in this comparison. Unknown bonus cards contribute zero to my totals. For New Worlds, pricing ten ordinary basic lands would tell us almost nothing about the appeal of the artwork, so I’ve left its replacement total blank.

Drop Existing nonfoil singles Nonfoil drop price My read
Lower Decks $28.02 $29.99 Closest to covering the purchase
tlhIngan maH $23.22 $29.99 Two cards carry most of it
Beam Me Up $10.96 $29.99 A substantial transporter-art premium
KHAAAAAAAAN $9.33 $29.99 Buy for the film treatment
New Worlds Art purchase $29.99 Ten basics, about $3 each

Those totals are useful for comparing the drops with one another. They’re less useful as promises of savings. Splitting a $28.02 singles order across several sellers can cost enough in shipping to change the comparison. Your local shop might have most of the cheap cards in one box. I’d check both before treating a difference of two dollars as a verdict.

And these numbers compare against the $29.99 nonfoil editions. Paying another $10 for foil is a separate decision about the treatment. Existing nonfoil singles can’t establish what the new foils will sell for.

Lower Decks gets very close

The five cards break down like this:

Existing card and printing Nonfoil USD
Inti, Seneschal of the Sun, LCI #156 $1.16
Kambal, Profiteering Mayor, POTJ #211p $5.13
Silas Renn, Seeker Adept, BRC #129 $2.22
Thrasios, Triton Hero, FCA #58 $18.18
Weatherlight, DOM #237 $1.33

Kambal’s price there is the promo printing. Thrasios is the earlier Final Fantasy: Through the Ages version. If you specifically want the original name displayed prominently on your card, that second comparison may feel unsatisfying, but a previous crossover is a perfectly reasonable alternative for someone buying the rules text.

The Star Trek versions turn those cards into Mariner, Boimler, Rutherford, Tendi, and the Cerritos. I can see why someone who wants the whole crew would pay the extra $1.97 over that basket, especially if it avoids a scattered singles order. EDHREC’s announcement has the character mappings and explains the other treatments too.

Owning Thrasios changes this purchase a lot. Cross off its $18.18 replacement cost and the four remaining cards add up to $9.84. If you’re replacing an existing copy with Tendi, decide where the old one goes before counting both as useful acquisitions. A trade binder is a destination. A vague intention to build another deck eventually is harder to price.

I keep wavering on this one. I’d normally say buying a second version of a card you already own is the easiest thing to cut from a cart. Then I look at Tendi and the dog again. Fine. I’d allow myself an art budget, provided I actually called it that when I wrote the purchase down.

The Klingon drop depends on which Seething Song you find

Existing card and printing Nonfoil USD
Demand Answers, MKM #306 $0.52
Relentless Assault, MB2 #132 $2.25
Seething Song, 9ED #216 $8.63
War’s Toll, BBD #187 $11.36
Warstorm Surge, FDC #186 $0.46

War’s Toll and Seething Song contribute $19.99 of the $23.22 total. The rest of the drop adds $3.23, which makes checking your existing red cards especially worthwhile. The reversible treatment has Klingon on one side and English on the other, according to the announcement. That makes the language treatment considerably easier to live with at a table.

A price-search trap showed up while I was checking Seething Song: a double-faced card with a face sharing that name appeared among the results. It has a different card identity, so I excluded it. The Ninth Edition instant linked above is the actual card being reprinted. Matching a name fragment would’ve knocked more than eight dollars off this total.

War's Toll from Battlebond, the existing $11.36 nonfoil printing used in the Klingon drop comparison

War’s Toll is also a card I’d read before casually adding it to a deck. Its land trigger and attack requirement can make a game feel quite different. A themed purchase still leaves you deciding whether you enjoy playing the cards that came with it.

I can picture the less dignified version of this purchase: someone orders the Klingon cards, practices saying the drop’s name, and then spends their first game turning every card over because they can’t remember the text. I’d be concentrating so hard on pronunciation that I’d forget the trigger. English backs were a sensible inclusion.

The transporter and Khan drops ask more for the pictures

Beam Me Up contains Eerie Interlude from SOI #16 at $6.98, Momentary Blink from DDQ #15 at $0.14, Essence Flux from SOI #61 at $1.15, and Conjurer’s Closet from DRC #126 at $2.69. That’s $10.96. The reversible illustrations move characters between danger and a transporter bay; the set has an unusually coherent visual idea.

I like that idea enough to understand the purchase. The extra $19.03 still belongs in the artwork column. If your goal is adding blink spells to a Commander deck, those existing versions leave quite a bit of the budget available for other cards. I’d also check what the deck needs to survive before buying another blink package; the protection-kit guide sorts out which effects handle which problems.

The Khan drop has six cards:

Existing card and printing Nonfoil USD
Wrath of the Skies, MH3 #49 $2.20
Commandeer, OTP #9 $3.63
Illusionist’s Gambit, WOC #97 $0.34
Buried Alive, CMD #74 $2.55
Genesis Wave, FDN #221 $0.37
Fracture, SOC #310 $0.24

At $9.33, it’s the weakest revealed spell drop by this measure. Six cards make the package look generous until you price them individually. I don’t know what premium fans will eventually pay for these particular movie scenes, and I’d leave that unknown rather than invent a resale cushion.

New Worlds is simpler to judge. Ten basic lands, two of each type, cost $29.99 nonfoil or $39.99 foil. That’s roughly $3 or $4 per land. If you want a deck full of matching planets, work out how many packs of ten that project would take before falling in love with the first ten.

Five foil drops still miss the promo threshold

The official offer is one foil Return of the Wildspeaker as “Transporter Boondoggle” for every $199.99 spent, while supplies last. The link shows an existing promo printing, currently $1.55 nonfoil; the Star Trek promo’s future price is unknown.

Five $39.99 foil drops add up to $199.95. Four cents short. All five nonfoil drops total $149.95. Wizards also says orders over $99 ship free under the applicable store terms. Those are US-dollar figures; check your regional storefront before budgeting around either threshold.

Oh, come on. Four cents. You can have decided to buy every revealed foil drop and still be looking for something else to add. I’d stop there for a moment. The sixth drop hasn’t been revealed yet, and buying another product solely to qualify gives that extra purchase a job it might be very bad at.

I wouldn’t assign the free promo a resale value before it exists in buyers’ hands. An ordinary copy’s price tells you what the game piece costs. The exclusive art might command more, but it doesn’t give us a verified number to subtract from today’s cart.

Eldwyn’s card list, useful for checking owned copies against a Secret Lair shopping list

Before November 9, I’d run the wanted cards against my collection, including copies sleeved into decks. In Eldwyn, checking the underlying card name also helps avoid treating a crossover name as a newly missing game piece. Our Stardates guide deals with the same naming problem in the main Star Trek release.

For anything left in the cart, I’d write down the edition, the finish, and what I paid. If Tendi is replacing a Thrasios, give the old copy a destination. Then leave the sixth drop’s space blank until Wizards actually shows it to us.