The Sword is doing a lot of work in Rise of the Polygons. Sword of Truth and Justice currently costs $28.21 in its ordinary Modern Horizons printing, which makes a $39.99 Secret Lair containing it look fairly appealing before you’ve even looked at the dragon. I’d check whether you own those two cards before deciding this drop saves you money.
Wizards’ Extra Life 2026 announcement confirms four cards and an Elemental token, all dressed up as a late-1990s polygon adventure. The new Balefire Dragon looks like something you’d fight after losing an entire evening to a platforming section. I like that more than I expected to.

Rise of the Polygons singles value, checked November 11
These are Scryfall USD reference prices for four existing nonfoil printings. They’re alternatives you could buy to play the cards, rather than resale estimates for the new artwork. I’ve left the token unpriced.
| Card | Existing printing | Nonfoil price |
|---|---|---|
| Balefire Dragon | Innistrad Remastered, INR 479 | $15.62 |
| Sword of Truth and Justice | Modern Horizons, MH1 229 | $28.21 |
| Young Pyromancer | Duel Decks: Mind vs. Might, DDS 20 | $0.24 |
| Big Score | Final Fantasy Commander, FIC 290 | $0.45 |
| Total | Four existing nonfoils | $44.52 |
At those reference prices, the $39.99 nonfoil drop sits $4.53 below the basket. The foil version costs $49.99, so you’re paying another $10 for that finish. This table doesn’t establish what an equivalent basket of existing foils costs.
I’ve used an ordinary-frame Sword for the comparison. Scryfall also reports a previously released Secret Lair Sword, SLD 1867, at $27.23. Choose that version instead and the basket falls to $43.54. There’s still a small gap in the drop’s favor, but postage could easily move either comparison around.
The Sword and Dragon contribute $43.83 of the ordinary-printing total. Young Pyromancer and Big Score together contribute 69 cents. They’re cards I’d happily play, but buying another copy of either barely changes the arithmetic. If your precon leftovers already contain Big Score, crossing it off saves less than a dollar.
Scryfall has entries for the new polygon versions, with no USD prices yet. I don’t know where those singles will settle after copies reach buyers. The $44.52 figure can’t tell us that, and it certainly doesn’t promise you’ll get your purchase price back by selling the contents. Our guide to what different MTG price figures actually mean covers why the number on a screen and your eventual proceeds can be quite far apart.
Cross off the cards you already have
Suppose you own the Dragon and want ordinary playable copies of everything else. The remaining basket is $28.90. Buying the drop means spending $11.09 more, before either route’s shipping, for the new treatments, the token, and another Dragon.
Own the Sword instead? The remaining three cards total $16.31. The nonfoil drop then costs $23.68 more than filling those gaps at the table’s reference prices. That’s a much bigger art purchase than the headline total suggests.
I’d run those names through Eldwyn, including the cards tucked into active decks, then check the want list against the collection. A Sword in a deck counts as a card you own. Whether you’re willing to move it is a separate question; keeping two decks ready to play can be a perfectly good reason to want another.
So, yeah. Open the deck box. Check the Equipment. Maybe the Sword’s already there. Maybe you want the new one anyway. I wouldn’t spend half an hour rummaging for the Pyromancer while leaving that question unanswered.

I started out leaning toward skipping this if you own either expensive card. Then I looked at the artwork again. A little four-card adventure with its own boss monster is a more coherent thing to collect than four unrelated fancy reprints. I’d understand buying it to keep together. I’d probably hesitate before splitting it across Commander decks, which rather undermines my own practical justification for wanting it.
The charity terms and the sale window
Online sales run November 16–30, ending at 1 a.m. Pacific on November 30. Wizards also lists limited quantities at MagicCon: Atlanta, November 13–15. The announced US prices are $39.99 nonfoil and $49.99 foil; check your regional checkout for the delivered total.
For the online drop, Wizards says 50% of the sales price, less third-party transaction fees, will be donated to Children’s Miracle Network through Our Change Foundation, supporting Extra Life and Seattle Children’s Hospital. That fee qualification means I wouldn’t describe the donation as an exact $20 or $25 per purchase. Wizards separately says proceeds from sales at the Extra Life booth go to Extra Life after third-party fees.
The charitable contribution makes me more willing to pay for art I enjoy. I’d still choose the finish before opening checkout, particularly if I’m already tempted to add more products to the order. Recording what you actually paid will be more useful later than remembering that the cards once added up to about forty-five dollars.
For my money, the nonfoil version is the interesting one if you want both expensive cards. If you already own them, decide how much you like the little polygon adventure. Leave the two copies you already own on the table while you look at the pictures.